29 Years Ago, Michael Keaton Walked Away from the Batman Role. Here’s Why.

The role of a lifetime

Years after the television adaptation led by Adam West and Burt Ward, Batman returned to the forefront in 1989, this time with a film adaptation directed by Tim Burton. For this new project, the filmmaker decides to hire Michael Keaton who lands here one of the biggest roles of his career. After a successful first feature film, Tim Burton and Michael Keaton repeated their efforts by bringing Batman Returns to fruition in 1992. Two now cult films which pushed Warner Bros. to further exploit the masked vigilante. And if the studio once again wanted to entrust the title role to Michael Keaton, a conflict with the new director finally put an end to this collaboration.

Subscribe to Canal+

One hero, two different visions

With Batman Forever, Joel Schumacher succeeds Tim Burton and Val Kilmer plays the main role. But originally, Michael Keaton was game to come back and wear the famous Dark Knight costume once again. The problem is that the actor did not at all adhere to the vision of the new filmmaker associated with the project. Michael Keaton and Joel Schumacher thus had two completely different visions of the character, as the actor revealed in 2022 on the media's podcast The Playlist.

It's always been about Bruce Wayne. No Batman. I knew it from the start. He (Joel Schumacher) asked me: “I don't understand why everything has to be so dark and sad.” And I said, 'Wait a minute, do you know why this man became Batman? Did you hear? I mean…it's pretty obvious.'

In the end, History proved Michael Keaton right. The more watered-down version of the DC hero thought up by Joel Schumacher did not at all convince the public, who still today consider Batman Forever and Batman & Robin as the two worst adaptations dedicated to the character. It was not until Christopher Nolan took over the hero in 2005 to finally find all the ingredients that make the Dark Knight one of the most popular superheroes of all time.